Arrow Shirts advertisement by J. C. Leyendecker
Dark Room ยท Icon

America's first male pin-up was the illustrator's partner

The Arrow Collar Man got more fan mail than movie stars. He was modeled on the man J. C. Leyendecker went home to.

By Dark RoomNovember 20265 min read

In 1905 J. C. Leyendecker created an advertising character for Cluett, Peabody and Company's Arrow collars: a handsome, square-jawed man in a perfect collar. The Arrow Collar Man became so popular that the company received piles of fan mail addressed to him, and he turned up in songs and on stage.

The model

The original model was Charles Beach. He also managed Leyendecker's business, and he was his partner for the rest of his life. From 1914 the two lived in Leyendecker's house and studio in New Rochelle, New York. Beach was in the ads, in the house and in the will. Millions of Americans looked at him every week without knowing they were looking at a love story.

Arrow Collars advertisement, J. C. Leyendecker 1907Arrow Shirts advertisement, J. C. Leyendecker 1920s
Left: Arrow Collars, 1907. Right: Arrow Shirts, 1920s.

The covers

Leyendecker painted 322 covers for The Saturday Evening Post between 1899 and 1943, one more than his admirer Norman Rockwell. He started the Post's long run of New Year's baby covers and painted a Santa Claus that became iconic. His men were athletic, elegant and a little too beautiful, and they defined what an American man was supposed to look like.

The Saturday Evening Post - football, J. C. Leyendecker 1908The Saturday Evening Post - Summer, J. C. Leyendecker 1927
The Saturday Evening Post: football, 1908, and "Summer," 1927.
Millions looked at him every week without knowing they were looking at a love story.

After

Leyendecker died in 1951, and Beach a few months later. Many of the original paintings were sold off cheaply after his death. Today the market has caught up: an original Arrow illustration from about 1932 sold for $20,625 at Heritage in May 2026.

Hang one

Leyendecker's work published before 1931 is now in the public domain in the United States, so the Arrow men and the Post covers on the Wall can be printed. They make a very good present for anyone who appreciates a collar.