British Columbia Mr. Leather, 1984
Dark Room No. 1 · Face of the year

The mustache never left

Castro Street in '77, the leather contests of '84, every gay bar in 2026. A short history of the most loyal accessory in gay life.

By Dark RoomThe Heat Issue · November 20266 min read

Grindr's own editorial team asked the question everyone had been thinking: why does every gay guy have a mustache now? The celebrity version of the trend has names attached: Timothée Chalamet, Jacob Elordi and Pedro Pascal are this year's most-cited faces, and the beauty press has a name for the look, the "slutty little mustache." Lovely. Now look at the archive.

Eugen Sandow, Eugen Sandow 1895
Eugen Sandow, 1895: the first celebrity bodybuilder, in his animal-skin costume. The mustache came standard. See the original.

The clone

In the late 1970s, on Castro Street in San Francisco, gay men landed on a uniform: flannel or a tight white tee, Levi's, boots, a bomber jacket, and a full mustache. The activist Arthur Evans named it in a series of posters he wheatpasted around the neighborhood: the clones. The sociologist Martin Levine later wrote the book on them, Gay Macho, arguing the look was a way to throw back the old insult that gay men were failed men. The style spread through the New York monthlies, Mandate, Playguy and Honcho, whose pages were full of it, and through the films of the era.

Flannel, The Falcon File Jun 1977Jake, Blueboy Mar 1979
Left: "Flannel," The Falcon File, 1977. Right: "Jake," a plaid shirt open to the waist, Blueboy, 1979.
José Rafael, Playguy 1979The pool, Honcho Aug 1980
Left: "José Rafael," a cigarette and a brick wall, Playguy, 1979. Right: the pool, Honcho, 1980.

Even the Village People were cast this way. When their producers went looking for singers, their ad in the Village Voice asked for macho types and added one requirement: must have mustache.

The clones wore it as armor. 2026 wears it as a wink.

Freddie

Freddie Mercury grew his in the early 1980s, reportedly inspired by the gay club scene in San Francisco, and wore it as part of a look that was flamboyant and coded at once. Stadiums full of people sang along to a man in the clone uniform.

1984: the contest

By 1984 the mustache had a podium. That year's regional Mr. Drummer winners, the title contest run by Drummer, the leather magazine, could have been cast from one barbershop: Southern California with a handlebar and a single chest strap, New England in aviators against a fence, British Columbia in a Muir cap and a zipped biker jacket.

Mr. New England Drummer, Mr. Drummer 1984Mr. Southern California Drummer, Mr. Drummer 1984
Left: Mr. New England Drummer, 1984. Right: Mr. Southern California Drummer, 1984.
Mr. Pacific Northwest Drummer, Mr. Drummer 1984
Mr. Pacific Northwest Drummer, 1984, on the mic under the EXIT sign. See the original.

2026

The difference now is tone. The clone wore his as armor, a way of looking like the men who had bullied him. This year's version, Grindr points out, travels with a broader workwear moment of Carhartt and heavy boots, and wears it with a wink. Either way, it is the same three-quarter inch of hair, doing the same job. The mustache never left. It just waited for everyone else to come back.

The Man: Corky Sevier, Mandate Nov 1980
"The Man: Corky Sevier," a Colt color centerfold. Mandate, November 1980. See the original.