A bearded man in a number 69 football jersey, 1977
Dark Room ยท Watch party

Before Heated Rivalry, there were the physique magazines

The secret romance between two rival athletes is the hottest show on TV. The fantasy is about 120 years old.

By Dark RoomNovember 20265 min read

Heated Rivalry, the gay hockey romance that premiered on Canada's Crave in November 2025 before landing on HBO Max, turned into the show everyone was talking about. HBO renewed it for a second season, its stars Hudson Williams and Connor Storrie carried the torch before the Milan Cortina Olympics, and at least one hockey player has come out crediting it. The fantasy at its center, the athlete who is supposed to be off-limits, is one of the oldest in the archive.

1908: the college man

J. C. Leyendecker painted football players for The Saturday Evening Post before most people owned a radio. The kick, the striped socks, the jaw: it is an action shot and a pin-up at the same time.

The Saturday Evening Post - football, J. C. Leyendecker 1908
J. C. Leyendecker, The Saturday Evening Post, 1908. See the original.

1950s: the warm-up

The physique photographers loved athletes because athletes gave them an excuse. Bruce of Los Angeles shot two champions warming up by a gym wall in 1955; the caption is about training, and the picture is not.

Champions warm up, Bruce of Los Angeles 1955Fred Storbeck, boxer, Bain News Service Undated
Left: "Champions warm up," Bruce of Los Angeles, 1955. Right: Fred Storbeck, boxer.

1970s and 80s: the jersey

After Stonewall the glossies stopped pretending. Jerseys, helmets and gym shorts became costume, and the number on the back started making jokes.

Tight End, Honcho Sep 1982The boxer, Honcho Sep 1979
Left: "Tight End," 1982. Right: "The boxer," 1979.
Pumping Iron, Blueboy Nov-Dec 1976
"Pumping Iron," 1976. See the original.
The athlete who is supposed to be off-limits is one of the oldest fantasies in the archive.

And hockey?

In a century of magazines we have football, boxing, wrestling, skiing and a great deal of bodybuilding, and not a single hockey player. Heated Rivalry is filling a real gap. If you know of one, write to us. And if a fan in your life needs a present, we have ideas.