Red Dust, a painting of a shirtless cowboy by George Quaintance, 1955
Dark Room ยท Trend report

Everyone is searching for homoerotic art. Here is where it came from

For a century it needed an alibi: advertising, fitness, the Wild West. Now the alibi is gone and the pictures are selling.

By Dark RoomNovember 20266 min read

On the art marketplace Catawiki, searches for "homoerotic" rose 175 percent from 2023 to 2024, and it is now one of the most searched art terms on the site. As far back as 2015 the V&A in London found "homoerotic" among its top ten search terms.

Catawiki makes a sharp point about the older work: for most of the twentieth century, artists and collectors needed an alibi, some other quality like composition or scenery that justified looking. The history of homoerotic art is really a history of alibis.

Alibi one: advertising

J. C. Leyendecker sold shirts, collars and suits with men so beautiful that the Arrow Collar Man got fan mail. The man in the ads was often his partner, Charles Beach. Nobody had to explain why they had torn the page out.

The Saturday Evening Post - Summer, J. C. Leyendecker 1927
J. C. Leyendecker, "Summer," The Saturday Evening Post, 1927. See the original.

Alibi two: the Wild West

George Quaintance painted cowboys bathing in creeks and wrangling in red dust, and sold them as Western art. The muscles were anatomically optimistic. More on the cowboys here.

Hero Worship, Physique Pictorial 1955Physique Pictorial - Fall 1957, Physique Pictorial Fall 1957
Left: "Hero Worship," 1955. Right: Physique Pictorial, Fall 1957.

Alibi three: fitness

The physique magazines claimed to be about health and classical form. The Etienne calendar put a different cowboy on every month, and you could hang it in the kitchen because it was, technically, a calendar.

Etienne calendar - August, Etienne (Dom Orejudos) 1963
The Etienne calendar, August 1963. See the original.

No alibi

Tom of Finland arrived in Physique Pictorial in 1957 and simply drew what he wanted, cropped by editors when the law required. His sailors and bikers made no excuses, which is why they still look modern. Read the origin story.

Tattooed Sailor and the Hoods, Physique Pictorial 1962
"Tattooed Sailor and the Hoods," Tom of Finland, 1962. See the original.
The history of homoerotic art is a history of alibis.

2026

This summer a Los Angeles show framed more than 70 artists as heirs to Tom of Finland, and Luke Evans wore a Met Gala look inspired by him. The work that once had to hide in a calendar now hangs in galleries. If you want to hang it at home, start here.